I haven't voted yet but im at a catholic high school and #1 is definetly how they operate. It kinda sucks i guess, but kids don't jack around as often. Some of my teachers are cool and let you goof off to some extent. More learning is definetly accomplished than at a public shool. Actually i am going to vote number 1 because public schools are pretty much doing #2 and that isnt working. I mean just look at where we rank compared to other industrialized nations. We aint good. I dont think the hair or clothes matter but punishments should definetly be stricter in public schools