In my experience, most girls don't take alot of intreast in fatty guys, or muscle heads, most of all the testosterone goes strait to there head. Most girls like well maintained guys, who take care of there bodies. So yeah muscular, but even they know when too much is to much. Hey some chicks are just retards tho so dont take what they like actually as what other girls like. Most of my x-girlfriends have been good looking and sexy, some that i dated way back in the day arent anymore, but either way, im a skinny guys with no acne and i keep my self well maintained and i got some muscle but not alot, and i still get the chicka's hope this helps man, once u hit a certain age alot of girls go for the personality more then anything but they do rate your looks and it could be a factor still.