You could definitely try those, but they sure are charging a lot of money for those supplements, and the sad thing is because they're not regulated by the FDA, they don't necessarily have to contain one iota of the stuff they claim to contain. So the truth is they may or may not have all those ingredients. (When tested a couple of years ago by a consumer magazine and news network working together, most natural supplements like that were found not to contain the ingredients they claimed to.) You'd probably do just as well trying your fish-oil Omega 3 capsules, and definitely don't rule out the option of trying the tear duct plugs. Lots of people find them easy to tolerate and wear them comfortably, and they have two or three types of plugs. Some work better than others. I'm going to try another type because the doctor told me not to rule them totally out till I'd tried all my options. Another thing that helped me was to increase my water intake. Good luck!