This goes in Feedback, Leaf. I'm going to put it there.

Just as an FYI, we mods close threads at our discretion based on how much continuing discussion there needs to be on a topic, not based on the rules necessarily. In the case of my deletion of the Saddam execution video, I left that questioning thread closed but visible so everyone could see the reasons behind the deletion of the execution video. But I wasn't going to invite further discussion on that decision because, frankly, the deleted thread went clearly against the disturbing pics rule (video, in case you didn't know it, falls into that category) and because there was no need for further discussion on that topic since the deletion of that thread was an easy, rules-based decision.

We'll let Sundance try to decipher the rest of your rule-revision plan and act accordingly if he sees fit.
birdgirl73 Reviewed by birdgirl73 on . Rule 12? On the forum rules I have a suggestion of a rule 12, no questioning about the decisions of a mod. The reason for this is because in all technicalities, there was no reason for the thread asking about why the sudam's hanging vid was nuked to be closed, because it broke no rules. And also, when concerning it, rule number ten states: No xxx stuff, disturbing pix It says nothing about disturbing Videos, this should also be changed. Rating: 5