Quote Originally Posted by Reefer Rogue
For the people who say they're over rated, I doubt you've listened to all of their albums. Also, for anyone to say that they are not one of the best bands ever, disregards the album sales and the long lasting position in the charts of darkside of the moon.
Don't be upset at peoples opinions.

I have listened to all their albums, plenty of times as that's what I was raised on, but I like music that is a little more upbeat. Their music is too slow and dreamy for me (despite the few songs).

They are not a Rock n Roll band, they do not rock out at all. They are mellow.

And album sales mean nothing to me. Britney Spears has sol millions of records, but she still sucks, you know.

It's just an opinion, and the question was if they are greatest rock n roll band ever, and no, I don't think they are.