Can God make a stone so heavy that even he cannot lift it? (Discussion)

[Inferius]

Before you can answer that question you must first ask a different question:

What is a "God"?

When I was religous, I did not believe in a God that was material, that a God that was a man or incarnated as a man as the Christians and Hindus do.

So to answer, I would say No, because God does not lift - that is something us humans do.

Thats what I would of said. This question is flawed, due to what you beleive is god. Rephrase it into something thats bound by our own logical laws, and then we can squabble.