Advice on CD

[LuckyNiner]

I'm making a CD for a girl. Cliche cliche, I know. However, I honestly haven't felt this way about someone for a long, long time, so I want this to mean something.

Anyway. Here are the songs I have so far. I would appreciate any recommendations that you think would be suitable. They don't necessarily have to be love songs, in fact I'm trying to be a bit more subtle than that. Just songs that are unique, special, beautiful, sad, moving, and it wouldn't hurt if the lyrics had something along the lines of rekindling an old flame, perhaps one that was never fully explored. Genres I'm thinking about: indie, alternative, classic rock, folk, I don't know..no rap, hip-hop, or country.

1. Jesus, etc. - Wilco
2. Morning Theft - Jeff Buckley
3. Bob Dylan's Beard - Wilco
4. Let's Not Shit Ourselves (To Love and to be Loved) - Bright Eyes
5. Susie Q - Creedence Clearwater Revival (her name's Susie)
6. Stickshifts and Safetybelts - Cake
7. Slow Like Honey - Fiona Apple

So that's it. Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

LuckyNiner Reviewed by LuckyNiner on 10-12-2006. Advice on CD I'm making a CD for a girl. Cliche cliche, I know. However, I honestly haven't felt this way about someone for a long, long time, so I want this to mean something. Anyway. Here are the songs I have so far. I would appreciate any recommendations that you think would be suitable. They don't necessarily have to be love songs, in fact I'm trying to be a bit more subtle than that. Just songs that are unique, special, beautiful, sad, moving, and it wouldn't hurt if the lyrics had something along Rating: 5

[thcbongman]

Since you like Wilco, you can't leave out I'm Trying To Break Your Heart, that's the most powerful love song of all time. Check out these songs:

Neutral Milk Hotel - In An Aeroplane Over The Sea
Elliot Smith - Everything Reminds me of her
David Garza - Float Away
Apples In Stereo - Lucky Charm
Sonic Youth - Do You Believe In Rapture?
Of Montreal - Don't Ask Me To Explain
Sunny Day Real Estate - Song About An Angel
Sunset Rubdown - Stadiums and Shrines II

[LuckyNiner]

Since you like Wilco, you can't leave out I'm Trying To Break Your Heart, that's the most powerful love song of all time. Check out these songs:

Neutral Milk Hotel - In An Aeroplane Over The Sea
Elliot Smith - Everything Reminds me of her
David Garza - Float Away
Apples In Stereo - Lucky Charm
Sonic Youth - Do You Believe In Rapture?
Of Montreal - Don't Ask Me To Explain
Sunny Day Real Estate - Song About An Angel
Sunset Rubdown - Stadiums and Shrines II

Those are some fantastic ideas.

Thank you so much.

[justinsane]

Ice Cube - You can do it (put yo ass into it)
36 Mafia - Im So High
Dr. Dre - Bitches Aint Shit
Sublime - 40oz. to Freedom

[Zoosh]

Dont mean to be rude but i think he's looking for something more meaningfull than "bitches aint shit"

Bedoin Soundclash - When the night feels my song
David Grey - Babylon
Jose Gonzalez - Heartbeats
Nujabes - Feather

[friendowl]

i dont think girls wanna listen to that bulshit
but what do i know

lets get it on-- marvin gaye
being with you ---smokey robinson
spell--- blue magic
closer i get to you---roberta flack
me and you---brenton woods
reunited-peaches and herb

guranteed to get em moist

[B u M b L ee K y]

I think a girl would laugh in my face if I tried to give her a CD. That's so cheesy and cheap.

[friendowl]

the trick is not to give it to her
just let her listen
and when shes under the spell
kiss her neck gently
becareful she dont get pregnant

[LuckyNiner]

Thanks to those who took it seriously.

[Frivolous248]

Well...I'd say Journey has some great songs, but you said you're trying to be subtle.

You might wanna try "Journey - Anyway You Want it" though.