Really i beg to differ.But have you taken two clones one under mh and one under hps? this was one of my first experiments when i got started i found the mh plants grew great in veg but in flowering it looked great also but the buds were nothing to compare with the hps the mh buds took longer and was scroney the hps plants flurished and were slightly shorter with beautiful top buds that i feel the hps made possible everyone has there own preferences so i just wanted to let you know what happened with mine and why i like to flower with hps