OK, I'd give some very diffferent advice from MastaChronic's in this instance.

If she's a game-player and rather judgemental about what you have and haven't done, just let it die like you seem to already have done. That's the fastest route to a happy ending. Don't call her back. Don't get into a game-playing, head-screwing cycle with her. Just let it go. Move above and beyond to greener pastures, meaning prettier, nicer, more open-minded girls who don't play back-and-forth games. They're out there. And you'll be happier when you meet one of them.