I adore David Gilmour far more than Roger Waters. David's guitar abilities are amazing, but then again Roger has a great talent writing some of the best lyrics ever. Roger is coming to either Philly or Pittsburgh next month I believe, which isn't too far from my location now.. some friends and I are going to try and hit that concert up.

I agree Billionfold, Syd was the heart and soul of the group before his decline into his crazy mental state. But I think Gilmour was a great replacement... for sure. Sorry to see Syd go though.