Results 11 to 20 of 46
-
08-22-2006, 09:11 AM #11Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by Transition Force
To apply the concept of the differences between capitalism and socialism simply:
You have 10 workers being paid $10 an hour, working 10 hours a day for a 5 day period. $5000 is the weekly budget to pay those 10 workers. Let's say revenues drop and the budget is reduced to $4000. In a more free-market economy, you would lay off 2 of them. In a more socialistic economy, you would retain 1 or all workers, but reduced their salaries as well as their happiness, and those released would be let-go with all kinds of social protection, such as unemployment benefits, or job-placement. Also the government plays a bigger role in managing the entities.
However I think bong is a little misunderstanding when he says socialism doesn't work, since concepts of socialism is used in America. Subsideries, worker-protections, welfare, providing roads & services, military, even your bank account up to $100,000 is insured by the FIDC. These are socialistic protections.
More socialistic countries with a hybrid free-market thrive everywhere in the world. France, Germany, The Netherlands, Sweden, China are just a few examples.
Free market isn't necessarily the best thing, because the extreme of that would be economic anarchy. That means you have to provide for your every need with no government assistance. It wouldn't be such a bad thing if there weren't socialistic controls, but imagine economic anarchy with social suppression. The world hasn't seen this extreme yet, but with the world embracing the power of the free-market, it is bound to happen.
The best is to have a mix of the two, like America, and Switzerland.Happiness only real when shared
-
08-22-2006, 02:47 PM #12Senior Member
Communism
We have a long, long way to go before we all "know the rules" and play by them... that's why communism isn't ready for the general population. If you want to see a working form of communism (albeit, with divine authority), look no further than some of the pacifist religious sects.
-
08-22-2006, 11:44 PM #13Senior Member
Communism
Communism has been tried and it simply doesn't work. At least not on a large, nation wide, scale. It could be done with a small group of like minded people, such as in a '60's style commune, but everyone participating would have to not only agree to the principle, but also agree 100% to what everyone in the society should or shouldn't have. Not many couples can achieve this goal let alone an entire country.
Contrary to what Oneironaut ,and his anarchistic dreams, believes it does go against human nature. People work in order to satisfy their wants and their needs. Those who work harder have more of those needs satified. It only makes sense. Why should person a work his ass off if he gets the same thing as person b who slacks off all day. Why should someone go to school, get an advanced degree, and become a technological innovator if, when all is said and done, he's going to get the exact same thing as the guy selling hot dogs on the street? He/she won't, it's that simple. Eventually everyone will just slack off and the society will collapse.
Unlike most of you I have actually lived in a "communist" country-China. Although in modern day China bears very little resemblance to true communism, when I lived there 10 years ago you could still see some of the negative effects. I would go into any of the state run department stores and see hundreds of people working there, and I mean hundreds. Funny thing, even with all those employees it was hard to get help. Most just sat around chatting with each other and would ignore you if you asked for help. Some would literally shoo you away. If you did manage to get someone to help they did it with a frown and as little effort as possible. Why? Because it didn't matter. If they acted that way they'd get their pay. If they busted their ass, had the best customer service, and the top sales they'd still get the same pay. Go to China now, however, and walk into any of the privately owned stores and you'll see something entirely differnt. You'll see employees jumping over each other to get to you and willing to do whatever it takes to get the sale. Why? Because there's an incentive to do so.
Bottom line: inanimate objects roll downhill. Unless there's some reward at the top of the hill, people will do the same.
-
08-22-2006, 11:59 PM #14Senior Member
Communism
THank you Fengzi.............. you put it pefect.
Why do kids these days think it can work?
They have no Idea about a free market system...........NONE.
-
08-23-2006, 02:17 AM #15Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by Fengzi
-
08-23-2006, 03:04 AM #16Senior Member
Communism
Fengzi, granted, human motivation and behavior is skewed toward external rewards and reinforcement, more money, more recognition etc. I suspect that even the large scale communist experiments caved to the simplicity of getting people (some) to do something through such devices. Capitalism resorts to the incentives bag of tricks to get people to do more, do it better, faster, and cheaper, and then do all of it all over again by outsourcing everything to capitalist start-up countries.
For what it's worth, communism and capitalism share a common problem with regard to human behavior: Neither system has figured out how to get people to do something for the intrinsic good of doing it while being a good person doing it.
-
08-23-2006, 04:10 PM #17Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by graymatter
-
08-23-2006, 04:11 PM #18Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by dopesmoker
-
08-24-2006, 11:22 PM #19Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by thcbongman
Originally Posted by thcbongman
Besides, as Katrina proved very, very well - Private Charities are far more effective (and generous) than the government is.
Originally Posted by thcbongman
-
08-25-2006, 02:51 AM #20Senior Member
Communism
Originally Posted by CultureCherryPopper
Advertisements
Similar Threads
-
The Bloody History of Communism
By Harvesthetic in forum PoliticsReplies: 2Last Post: 01-30-2006, 08:50 PM -
Berkeley still celebrating communism
By amsterdam in forum PoliticsReplies: 0Last Post: 10-24-2005, 01:41 PM -
Conscription = Communism
By pisshead in forum PoliticsReplies: 5Last Post: 06-01-2005, 02:52 PM