From what I've read so far, his story has too many holes in it. There's a question about the timing since he said he went to her school to kidnap her, but it was during the holidays and school wasn't in session. They also question motivation; he says it was accidental, but apparently the injuries were very extensive and not what one would consider comes from an accident.

But you gotta figure...there has to be something there. He was familiar with the family, he's been caught in compromising sitatuations before, one of which I think cost him a job in Alabama. There has to be some sort of connection. If he didn't do it, I wonder if he knows who did or what happened. It's all bizarre!