I've heard both those arguements before. Personally I'm uncircumsized, but as for it being uncleanly, take 15 seconds in the shower to pull it back and wash it and your set, and if you don't shower daily... well, to each his own.

And I dunno about you guys, but me, and anyone else I've talked about it to, retracts upon erection... so this buisness about it being better? Isn't it the same thing?

Well, unless it's too tight, but you grow out of that in most cases. I've talked to chicks who both prefer one or the other, but if your using a condom, once again... same diff?

The only thing about circumcision I don't like is the actual cutting... *cringe* Other than that, I'd be happy either way, sex is sex.