OK these are mostly a lot older than apparently all the previous ones, but some of the older people in here might recognize some of these.....

Danny's Song--Kenny Loggins

Tears in Heaven-- Eric Clapton

The Living Years-- Mike and the Mechanics

I will Remember You-- Sarah McLaughlin

After All-- Peter Cetera

Endless Love-- Either version (Lionel Ritchie and Dianna Ross or Luther Vandross and Mariah Carey)

I'm sure there's countless more since I tear up at the drop of a hat. These are just a few that come to mind as sure things.
Mingles Reviewed by Mingles on . songs that make you cry (tear) songs that make me cry: Back in France by For Stars I will Follow You Into the Dark, What Sara Said by Death Cab for Cutie Scarlet Begonias by Sublime (don't ask me why) My Beautiful by Lennon Desert Garden by Vast The Places You Have Come to Fear the Most by Dashboard Confessional (they make everyone cry, those emo bastards) Susan Across the Ocean by the Silos These Hands by Deadwitt Rating: 5