Tight all the way, my girl was a virgin when we met, now she's tight and a veteran, we fuck like almost everyday, she loves it, i love it, so it's all good... I've had a loose girl, but it was arite still, i don't fuck with whores, so i don't know about super loose pussy, that'd probably suck, at the end of the day pussy is pussy and you'll still bust a nut everytime.....