I prefer girls who have had a few longterm boyfriends who they have screwed...Im not into easy girls...I mean sure, sex is fun and all, but sometimes a little patience is a good thing. I have gotten with a girl who must have had helium in her ankles and i thought she would be more experienced...what a dissapointment that turned out to be.
Also, my first gf was a virgin, but you could easily mistake her for a dead fish if you weren't careful...not very exciting.
Apparently, some girls have larger cavities naturally so sex for the first time is less painful. Plus, if she is a virgin, I always lube it up with a little tongue action and then break the ice with a finger or two. If she is digging that, I'll let her have it (gently ofcourse)...theres nothing worse than a girl turned prude because she had horrific sex with a retard for the first time.
One last thing, a girl who has done it only once or twice before makes me feel good about myself because I am way better in comparison (normally) thanks to a little advice on thrusting from some folks here. plus this one (attractive) german exchange student who was four years older than me taught me a thing or two about how to please her... I am all for multi-culturism especially when it comes to the "scissors" position.
for those unfamiliar with this one, you basically just put her on her side, spread her legs and give it a go (its like two scissors meshing...)
good times