Yea considering the target audience is pretty much everyone that watches the WB I'd have to agree to a certain extent. I do still think that the first season (or at least most of the first half) was an excellent show. The writing was just great. It was one of those shows that my wife wanted to watch so I let her watch it while I played a game. I ened up watching the whole episode and I've been watching it ever since. Same shit happened when she wanted to watch the notebook. I didn't want to watch it, but by the end of it, the controller was down and I was just sitting there watching it like you would a train wreck.