R.I.P Hilary Puff

[Its a Plant]

It took us forever to convince him to even pay HALF of it. and he's only going to do it in payments of 5 dollars a week.

I would maybe do some more "convincing" until he says he'll pay all of it. I dont see how you have to talk someone into replacing something that wasn't theirs. That's just common courtesy. I would at least have him smoke you up a lot then..something..