i'm just trying to get everyone to understand what they're saying and how it could effect even the ones suggesting it. can you honestly say you'd still be for it if say, the person you love the most in the world and couldn't even take hearing they got locked in jail for 2 yrs. were convited of the crime and then they were subjected to what you propose? yes sexual assualt is a major fuckin problem right now, and i fully agree something more than what's happening now drasticly needs to be done, but what most are suggesting is just plain out barbaric and in-humane, and even if us did implement such laws, do you really think they'd take the time to specify which ones are deserving and which aren't? i don't think so, i think they'd just stick with the "under 18 and your fucked" law i've said it before in this topic and i'll say it again, maybe i'm just way more empathetic than most, but the whole idea of subjecting them to such punishment doesn't really seem logical, or sane for that matter. i can't really say much more than that about why it shouldn't be ok to do such things, since i can't (and have tried for the past 2 or 3 weeks) find an alternative to what they are recieving now. it's stastical fact that most that are "rehabillitated" aren't really that way (think it's something like 80% of them will re-offend) but that is still 20% of the people that were: incapable of making coherent discions due to any number of reasons, framed people or ones that decided they couldn't wait another few months to bang the neighbors daughter, or idiots who mad horrible choices, being subjected to such things. i just can't understand it i've put my self in the shoes of if a loved one commited such an act, and then recieved this type of punishment, and just to think how it'd feel if my brother became a forced std carrier to be tested on (like i said, i don't think they'd just stick it to dna evidence, i think they'd do it to anyone that pleades no contest, guilty or is convicted/ajudicated of such a crime)


the only proposal i could possibly think of, just wouldn't work. send them all to their own island, basicly like a giant prison, and force all to wear tracking devices to ensure they don't escape. well i guess noone here really sees it the way i do