McCauley Caulkin feels that the reason might be because you have a tiny penis, and therefore did not reach her "cherry" the first time, hahaha.

j/k dude.

your probably hung like a horse
































.......fly
McCauley Caulkin Reviewed by McCauley Caulkin on . Why didn't I pop her cherry the first time we had sex? Okay, so I just had sex for the second time with my girlfriend. She was a virgin before i had sex with her last Saturday. On Saturday everything went just as it should except her cherry didnt pop. I just figured she got rid of it herself. Today as soon as I inserted she started bleeding and claimed i just popped her cherry! WTF?! is this possible?! Insight please?! Rating: 5