Yes, I am sure I had the right hole both times. Even she didnt know what to make of this. She said this happened to one of her friends but she didnt know either...
ilovebecky Reviewed by ilovebecky on . Why didn't I pop her cherry the first time we had sex? Okay, so I just had sex for the second time with my girlfriend. She was a virgin before i had sex with her last Saturday. On Saturday everything went just as it should except her cherry didnt pop. I just figured she got rid of it herself. Today as soon as I inserted she started bleeding and claimed i just popped her cherry! WTF?! is this possible?! Insight please?! Rating: 5