Well, I think almost any cologne scent is nice as long as it's not overkill.

As for scents, did you know that on the list of top 5 smells women are attracted to, sandalwood is the best smell a man can go with? It's all about pheramones, baby! Find a cologne containing sandalwood, or, better yet, find natural sandalwood oil, available in most head shops for less than $4!!!! You'll have women all over you.