If I am reading you correctly, she only took 4000 mg of creatine, that's only 4 grams. It's been a long time since I loaded (I sub exclusively now) creatine monohydrate that I had bought from GNC, but if I remember correctly it was 5 grams per serving and I could easily tolerate 5 servings a day for 3 days before the test. That's 25,000 mg a day x 3 days. She drank too much and loaded too little creatine.

I'd sub.