OK, here are the PH results:
Well water PH: 7.5
Composted Horse manure w wood shavings that I put on top of the soil, PH: 7.5
Soil: When mixing the 7.5 water with the soil and then testing the 'mud' it comes to 8.2, so I am assuming that my soil PH is at least 8.5 if not a little higher.

Make sense? Can I just keep watering with 6.2 water or would it be better to work some peat moss into the soil?