Well, I've actually fucked both oddly enough. I ended up with a preppy uber feminine chick for like 3 years. The vagina was absolutely wonderful. Never smelled bad or tasted bad somehow.

Then I met molly. Who is absolutely the wittiest, most wonderful female I've ever met. And I'm not a big fan of her vagina, nor is she a big fan of my penis. She'd probably fit into the 'different' category, rather then the punk category.

So here's my advice: Have lots of penis-vaginal intercourse with the preppy girl. And have lots of brain-brain intercourse with the 'punker' chick.