Well, here's the topped one. It's not seeming like it's progressing much. I flushed it again today and then gave it a light feeding. Very few trichs, crispy leaves. I gave it a Cal/Mag boost last week. It's looking crispy even though it's had water, I'm pretty sure I'm not overwatering, but then again it doesn't seem to be taking much up lately. Under the microscope the trichs are small and about 100% cloudy.