I don't think there is anything wrong with asking for proof when someone tries to pass something off as fact. I also don't think there is anything wrong for asking for a control when that person then says it's an experiment. I also don't think there is anything wrong with pointing out these 2 things when the person refuses to acknowledge that they could be wrong without any credible evidence to back them.

Rusty might have come across as brash but I feel his intentions were good.

FYI; I'm tired about hearing of the Farmers Almanac. The farmers Almanac is not the end all debate stopper. As a matter of fact 1/3 - 1/2 of the things in the almanac are just ridiculous or plain wrong. Personally when trying to back someone up I wouldn't source a reference that is known to contain as much bad information as it does good.

Horticulture/agriculture is a science. Let's practice good science and not hoodoo voodoo.
daihashi Reviewed by daihashi on . Gardening by The Moon- a discussion of the technique Hey, don't know if anybody but me believes in this...... The moon will be in Cancer on Nov.15th @2:52 pm EST until Monday Nov 17 until 4:06 pm EST. This is a good time to germinate seeds if anyone needs help germinating. The moon will be in the 3rd quarter which helps develop roots.....Best to not plant right near times given, as that is the time sign is changing. Hope this helps, if so let me know, as I am interested. Rating: 5