My Argument Against God

[L Rag]

Sup everyone, here's a little argument I made up to try to disprove the existence of god.. feel free to criticize and point out flaws, I wanna make it a very strong argument... Anyway cheers, and enjoy

P1: If god exists, he has existed forever, and nothing has existed before him.
P2: Therefore, god must have existed for an infinite period of time before the present.
P3: There is no reason for a god to exist but not cause any other existence.
P4: Therefore, god must have created the world as soon as he began to exist.
P5: If god created the world as soon as he began to exist, there is a finite time period between
the beginning of the world and the present.
P6: But god has never begun to exist, as he has existed forever.
P7: Therefore there is an infinite time period between the beginning of the world and the
present.
P8: P5 and P7 could not possibly be true at the same time.
C: Therefore, god does not exist.

L Rag Reviewed by L Rag on 04-15-2008. My Argument Against God Sup everyone, here's a little argument I made up to try to disprove the existence of god.. feel free to criticize and point out flaws, I wanna make it a very strong argument... Anyway cheers, and enjoy :) P1: If god exists, he has existed forever, and nothing has existed before him. P2: Therefore, god must have existed for an infinite period of time before the present. P3: There is no reason for a god to exist but not cause any other existence. P4: Therefore, god must have created the Rating: 5

[L Rag]

Come on, I know there are tonnes of theists out there who would love to prove me wrong...

[THClord]

I have a couple:

- who created god?
- if you religous people really know so much more than atheists, then why are you always wrong?
- if god really does exist, why would he want his believers brainwashed to obey all authority and start endless bloodshed whenever their leaders want to? If he really does want this, god sucks. But if he doesn't, then all you religous people are just pissing god off and only the atheists please him.

Sorry for the exaggerations and generalizations, I'm just trying to prove a point.

[L Rag]

I have a couple:

- who created god?
- if you religous people really know so much more than atheists, then why are you always wrong?
- if god really does exist, why would he want his believers brainwashed to obey all authority and start endless bloodshed whenever their leaders want to? If he really does want this, god sucks. But if he doesn't, then all you religous people are just pissing god off and only the atheists please him.

Sorry for the exaggerations and generalizations, I'm just trying to prove a point.

Hahaha bro did you read the argument? Did you even read the title of the thread? I'm not arguing for god..........I'm an atheist..... What the fuck...

[katyowns]

I don't really get why anyone argues about religion. It's something that almost never ends well and no one ever gets "swayed to the other side". We need to respect others choices, that goes for both believers and atheists. The idea of live and let live could solve a lot of problems in this world.

[zeitgeist]

I have a couple:
- who created god?

Not every question can be answered

- if you religous people really know so much more than atheists, then why are you always wrong?

Not all believers act like they know it all. There are know it alls everywhere. Especially atheists. And how can we be wrong if it is impossible to prove us wrong?

- if god really does exist, why would he want his believers brainwashed to obey all authority and start endless bloodshed whenever their leaders want to? If he really does want this, god sucks. But if he doesn't, then all you religous people are just pissing god off and only the atheists please him.

Soooooo Easy. Think about it. Would you want your children to have natural love for you or would you want "artificial" love. He gives us all our own mind to think for ourselves, and just like your parents he is not going to interfere within your whole life. People create problems, it is our obligation to fix them


When has anyone dispoved God? You cant because its impossible. Pretty much all the reasons an atheist uses, the same reasons can be used to disprove his/her own theories. Then where are we at the end of the day? The exact same spot.
Either you believe or you dont. Period

[Readytoride08]

Sup everyone, here's a little argument I made up to try to disprove the existence of god.. feel free to criticize and point out flaws, I wanna make it a very strong argument... Anyway cheers, and enjoy

P1: If god exists, he has existed forever, and nothing has existed before him.
P2: Therefore, god must have existed for an infinite period of time before the present.
P3: There is no reason for a god to exist but not cause any other existence.
P4: Therefore, god must have created the world as soon as he began to exist.
P5: If god created the world as soon as he began to exist, there is a finite time period between
the beginning of the world and the present.
P6: But god has never begun to exist, as he has existed forever.
P7: Therefore there is an infinite time period between the beginning of the world and the
present.
P8: P5 and P7 could not possibly be true at the same time.
C: Therefore, god does not exist.

You will be respected here.You have some good point of views,but explain this too me......can you explain a 120% in increased storms,the Tsuamni,plague slowly coming into the world?

The Prohecy's are coming correct,God made it clear the time they would come true,when man douted his existance.I can understand why some of you may be turned off,but soon I believe your mind will be changed.

[40oz]

Well maybe your idea of what "god" is has been perverted by religion. God isn't some man with a beard living in the sky creating things for fun. God is everything, god is infinite. God is the substance of existance.


Of course, this is just one way to look at the world if you like the idea of a god.

Sup everyone, here's a little argument I made up to try to disprove the existence of god.. feel free to criticize and point out flaws, I wanna make it a very strong argument... Anyway cheers, and enjoy

P1: If god exists, he has existed forever, and nothing has existed before him.
P2: Therefore, god must have existed for an infinite period of time before the present.
P3: There is no reason for a god to exist but not cause any other existence.
P4: Therefore, god must have created the world as soon as he began to exist.

P3 is just your opinion, so your proof is invalid. Especially if you look at the matter from the perspective that god is existance.

[THClord]

- who created god?

Not every question can be answered

Exactly my point

[pinkyslayer]

Sup everyone, here's a little argument I made up to try to disprove the existence of god.. feel free to criticize and point out flaws, I wanna make it a very strong argument... Anyway cheers, and enjoy

P1: If god exists, he has existed forever, and nothing has existed before him.
P2: Therefore, god must have existed for an infinite period of time before the present.
P3: There is no reason for a god to exist but not cause any other existence.
P4: Therefore, god must have created the world as soon as he began to exist.
P5: If god created the world as soon as he began to exist, there is a finite time period between
the beginning of the world and the present.
P6: But god has never begun to exist, as he has existed forever.
P7: Therefore there is an infinite time period between the beginning of the world and the
present.
P8: P5 and P7 could not possibly be true at the same time.
C: Therefore, god does not exist.

P3 is your downfall man. I wish you the best of luck with this argument, but your assumption that there is no reason for a god to exist without creating another existence may seem reasonable to us, but when applied to the concept of GOD, an omnipotent, omniscient being who controls and sees everything, doesnt quite make sense. we cannot presume to know what makes 'sense' to a God that presumably is the most powerful, intelligent, self-sufficient being in the universe. Also, the thing about people using religion to start wars isn't fair to religion. Those wars are the product of man's greed and ignorance in most every case, not the actual will of 'God'. Peace.