This is an opportunity to stress the buddies thing.
What would you get your guy friends if you had to get them a gift? Take her to a hockey game, or a totally not romantic concert, or a comedy show. What about a gift certificate for a store that doesn't carry anything even remotely girly? My old triathalon-training-buddy-with-benefits got me a gift certificate to a running shop so I could get some nice kicks. It was AWESOME, and I'm actually wearing them now, but totally not romantic at all. That would have just been silly.

Think PRACTICAL! Impractical gifts scream romance... lol...