Quote Originally Posted by Billionfold
You didn't understand what I said I guess... he could know exactly what we're going to do, but then if er change our mind, then what he sees will change at that moment.
I'm not sure if your contraction means "we were" or "we are". usually it wouldn't matter, but since we're talking about supposed futures and tenses are getting switched, it's a big deal

In any case, if God didn't know that I was going to change my mind, then he doesn't know everything. If god doesn't know exactly how my life will transpire, that means he is not the all knowing. it wouldn't matter to us on earth (the ones that can't see the entire future) what we perceive as a choice. if I ever change my mind about something, god knew of that change before i was born. Even my supposed choices are made before I was born.

If god can only see the choices I make as I make them, then he isn't all knowing. How can he be all knowing if he didn't know my 'choices' before they're made?

====================
Actually, come to think of it, an all knowing being and anall powerful being can't even coexist. If a being is all powerful, then it can do whatever it wants. If a being is all knowing, then it knows everything in the past present and future. How can the future be defined to an all powerful being? The all powerful being should have the power to change the future. If the all powerful being could do so, the all knowing being would be wrong, and therefore, not all knowing. The fact that these two ideas are supposed to belong to a single entity makes it worse, as the being can't exist.
====================

Man I love weed, I have to read this tomorrow. I put it in equal signs because I love it