Should I trade my SG for a Les Paul?

[MadSativa]

david who ........haha just kiding pink Floyed right

[Zannies]

yeahhhhhh man pink floyd

[TallCoolOne]

Don't forget Les Paul...he was a fairly famous Les Paul user as well, plus he was a magnificent player and invented multitrack recording on top of it all.

Regarding the poll: it is hard to answer unless one has played both axes for feel and also through the same amp for tone. No two LPs or SGs are the same. I would say LP if I had to make a decision at knifepoint.

Right now im using a Fender amp. As for tone, i play slide, and have been really dissapointed in the SG's sound on glass, metal and ceramic slides. The standard gibson pickups on it arent very good at all. I'm definately going for the LP now after some suggestions.

[Zannies]

yeah on my LP, one broke and i have to get it fixed when i get some more money, but it still sounds great.

[MadSativa]

yeah pink floyd is dope I like all their albums not all the songs but deffinitaly most of em, I like alot of texmex and rancheras and the fenders are perfect for those tones and play is natural

[Zannies]

yeah i dont like some songs on meddle, idk why its my avatar its not my favorite album...but echoes is prolly my favorite song

[connector_robot]

I'd trade for a Les Paul. They kick ass. Especially mine, which is a Jimmy Page signature edition. Cost me 15,000 Australian $'s though.

[skiddy]

yes trade the sg for the les paul =) i have a les paul its so amazing alpine white costum =)

[Blindman0v0]

Ever checked out Carvin?
Some nice axes.

[horror business]

Personally I'd prefer the SG, since you say the both sound good. I used to have a Les Paul, a Epiphone Black Beauty. It was nice, but I prefer the more sleek design of the SG.