As an english man i say yes scotland should be independant. I don't see why scots should have a say on english polocies where as english don't get a say on scottish ones. If the scots want independance as they all say they do then go independant it's no big deal to us english, mind you there are loads of "proud scots" plying their trade in england that you might want to call back home to help with the economy up there.

Laters.