Zig zags white for me, or any kind of 100% all natural hemp paper. Skunk Brand comes to mind. They are a tad bigger than standard size zigs, but they are a nice, thin paper, and it's all natural, even the glue strip.

I find novalty papers get expensive too. A pack of Zigs Whites is only $1 for a pack of 100 papers, so you can't go wrong there.