The two links in my signature show both cab and a closet grow... same exact equip ie lights etc that were in the cab were put in the closet. Compare for yourself... but i basically trippled the overall yield per grow moving from a cab to a closet on the same equip. More space to grow in is always a good thing imho.

Cabinets are great for stealth, and easier to do outside/inside/structure modification, and unless you own your dwelling, you cant exactly modify the closet (i rent and it does suck because i would LOVE to punch a hole through the one side of the closet to run ventilation but i cant)

Honestly, no one way is better than another... Ultimately, it boils down to what works best for you and your situation

Good luck w/ your grows!!! :thumbsup: