Printable View
usually when amy lee does a cover it's nothing short of excellent... but damn... =/
http://youtube.com/watch?v=3v0dL8-s9jk
it's actually a sad time for me... such a beautiful voice, nice song, but she just couldn't pull it off....
what do you think? am i the only one that thinks it just sucks? (this of course means you know the original song she's singing)
i cant give it a thumbs up or down... as i dont really know her true potential, but i have heard korn do this song, and as far as that goes, korn takes the cake.
or should i say... cob? :stoned:
imho, she probably has more potential than any other female singer on the rock side of music (i.e. not on the rap/pop/r&b side) she even has more potential then alot of male rock singers... or male singers period.... her voice is just intoxicating... she has EXTREMELY critical control over her voice.... she's amazing, but this... just damn man i'm so disappointed...Quote:
Originally Posted by justinsane
ok, download heart shaped box, for comparison, technically that was live too... the only diffrence is one was done infront of a live audience and one in a radio station.
I would have to give it a thumb's down.
well she isn't kurt cobain either.... she did a damn good job on heart shaped box... she isn't chester bennington either, she did a damn good job on numb as well.... i'm not really here to argue, especially with you billion lol... i was just expecting like a total mind blowing (but diffrent) version of it... and i was greeted wtih that =/
btw <.< just becuase it's bugging me, his name isn't spelled with a h, it's just Jonathon.
lol how come out of that post all you quoted was the davis thing?
no, i was just curious lol.. figured you might of meant to say something to it but forgot? i dunno..
NO! go back and do it again... quote ALL of my posts this time! :)
all 7000+ of them.
That band always makes me laugh!
Amy Lee's voice reminds me of a 13 year-old girl singing in the shower.
thumbs down - boo!
Whether or not you like the music, you must recognize talent. If you can't do that, you must be hung up on the, "Yo mang I got dat muhsaydeez benz na'm sayn nukka".
lol it was meant to be modern rap but it came out like shit and I didn't realize it until the edit button was gone. Blah... :D
I recognize the talent (in the band) which is why I DO like the music.Quote:
Originally Posted by invoke
Vocalists of Amy Lee's caliber are a dime-a-dozen.
I would enjoy Evanescence much better if they were an instrumental band.
This is just my opinion - I guess I am kind of jaded on the subject of contemporary music
How come in the first post you said that you thought she sounded like a thirteen year old and it made you laugh but in the second you recognize her talent? :confused: I'm confused
It's simple:Quote:
Originally Posted by KindMidasSoundman
I like the BAND (Drums, Bass, Guitars, Keyboards) but I don't care for the VOCALIST (Amy Lee)
Hence the comment:
Quote:
Originally Posted by KindMidasSoundman
Oh! I didn't even see that part. My bad, forgive me. :thumbsup:
No harm, no foul! :joint1:Quote:
Originally Posted by invoke
Sounds like a challenge! PayPal me a dime and I'll post the list.Quote:
Originally Posted by Billionfold
Now calm down - as I said I am just stating MY opinion. If I were to provide you with such a list you would simply disagree with me (my opinion) and we could go in circles like that forever. This is a highly objective subject.
*raises hand* i can give 2....Lacuna Coil and um um...wth is the other one..oh yea....The GatheringQuote:
Originally Posted by Billionfold
Check out this cover by Blue Man Group doing the Who's Baba O'Reily.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=Ldxg87pDlI8
BTW: Is that Tracey Bonham?