Should he be tried for murder?

Murder charges filed in Calif. train wreck

January 27, 2005

BY ROBERT JABLON ASSOCIATED PRESS




GLENDALE, Calif.-- The suicidal man who authorities say caused the chain-reaction train derailment that killed 11 people has been charged with multiple counts of murder and could face the death penalty, the district attorney said Thursday.

Juan Manuel Alvarez, 25, left his sport utility vehicle on a railroad track Wednesday after changing his mind about committing suicide, authorities said. He was held without bail at a hospital's jail ward after apparently slitting his own wrists and stabbing himself in the chest.

In addition to the 11 dead, a woman remained missing and nearly 200 people were injured.

Los Angeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley said prosecutors filed charges late Wednesday for 10 counts of murder with "special circumstances" of committing murder through a train derailment. Cooley stressed however that the case were still being evaulated. Under state law, special circumstances allegations could make a defendant eligible for the death penalty.

Cooley said the complaint would be amended to add another count to refer to the 11th victim, found in the wreckage late Wednesday night. And he said the defendant's suicidal intent didn't make any difference to him.

"He's not going to engage my sympathy because he was despondent. His despondency doesn't move me," the district attorney told The Associated Press.

Arraignment was planned for Thursday afternoon but could be delayed depending on Alvarez's medical condition.

Alvarez, 25, got out of his green Jeep Cherokee before the two commuter trains crashed Wednesday morning in this Los Angeles suburb. He stood by as the gruesome chain-reaction wreck scattered wreckage and bodies over a quarter-mile of track.

The SUV was stuck between tracks away from a crossing and once there, he could not have moved it even if he had tried, Metrolink CEO David Solow said. The southbound train that struck it bolted skyward, hit a parked Union Pacific railcar, then clipped the northbound train.

Sheriff Lee Baca said Thursday on CBS' "The Early Show" that "he was rather astounded himself as to what the outcome was" when the train hit the vehicle.

The crash was the worst U.S. rail tragedy since March 15, 1999, when an Amtrak train hit a truck and derailed near Bourbonnais, Ill., killing 11 people and injuring more than 100.

"I hope that we're able to assess this in a way that we can figure out: Is there a way that we can stop one crazed individual from creating this kind of carnage?" Los Angeles Mayor James Hahn told reporters.

Among the two women and nine men killed was a Los Angeles County sheriff's deputy on his way to work. About two dozen people were hospitalized in critical condition.

Glendale Fire Chief Christopher Gray said early Thursday that authorities were still actively looking for a 12th person who remained missing.

Alvarez's estranged wife, Carmelita Alvarez, had ordered him out of her home months ago, her family said, and in December she obtained a temporary restraining order keeping him away from her, their 3-year-old son and other family members.

"He is using drugs and has been in and out of rehab twice," she said in asking for the restraining order. "He threatened to take our kid away and to hurt my family members." She said he was "planning on selling his vehicle to buy a gun and threatened to use it."

Carmelita Alvarez, who lives in a converted garage behind her sister's home in suburban Compton, also told the court her husband had threatened to seek revenge on people he suspected of introducing her to another man. She said his drug use was triggering hallucinations.

She went into seclusion shortly after the crash.

"Whether we make any comment right now depends on my sister," her brother, Ruben Ochoa, told The Associated Press outside the family home on Wednesday. "We're not commenting right now."

The crash victims included several public employees, including Los Angeles County sheriff's Deputy James Tutino, 47, whose flag-draped body was saluted by law enforcement officers and firefighters as it was carried from the wreckage.

The force of the collision, which happened about 6 a.m., hurled passengers down the trains' aisles.

"I heard a noise. It got louder and louder," said Diane Brady, 56, of Simi Valley. "And next thing I knew the train tilted, everyone was screaming and I held onto a pole for dear life. I held on for what seemed like a week and a half, it seemed. It was a complete nightmare."

First on the scene were workers at a Costco store next to the tracks, who helped remove some of the injured in shopping carts. Uninjured passengers also joined the rescue effort.

Costco employee Hugo Moran said an elderly man, covered in blood and soot and with apparently broken arms and legs, was pulled out of the wreckage but died soon after. Before he died, he thanked his rescuers and asked them to pray for him.

Another trapped man had used his own blood to write a note on a seat bottom. Using the heart symbol, he wrote "I love my kids" and "I love Leslie."

The man's identity wasn't known, but Los Angeles Fire Department spokesman Capt. Rex Vilaubi said he was removed from the wreckage alive.


Contributing: AP writer Laura Wides.

hell yes!!

why would he leave his car on the tracks after he left?

omg thats awful:confused: Im not sure how i feel about that situation im kinda shocked atm :(.

Hell yeah he should be put down. He obviously doesn't care about other human life (let alone his own), so why should other human life care about him?

Bury him.

yes, he should be made to stand in front of another train after the courts spend millions prosecuting him.

Even if he's crazy he should be locked up for the rest of his life

yes, i think he should be prosecuted. he was very selfish in the way he chose to "cry for help." he obvilously doesnt value life at a meaningful level. neither his own , nor others.

yes yes yes

HE KILLED 11 PPL

HE WILL AND SHOULD GET THE DEATH PENALTY.

IF U WANNA KILL YA SELF DO IT ONT TAKE 11 INNOCENT LIVES TOO. THATS SELFISH AND FUCKED UP.

HIS SELFISH ACT CAUSED DAMGE HURT AND KILLED 11 PPL HE DESERVES TO DIE 11 TIMES.

:-)

i agree he should be done for killing 11 people and injuring 200....i dont really beleive in the death sentace because i think it is an easy way out.....so he should be imprisoned for ever

or bummed every 2 horus of his life

lmfao for sure that would serve him right

yea man definatly they should make homophobic inmates fuck him cos then that wud b funny lol

VOTE FOR ME AS YOUR PRESIDENT

Good call az! Didn't even think of that.

He wants to die, yet his ironic fate should be to rot in prison for years and years.




In the words of Mr. Burns:

Excellent!

dnt 4 get the hourly bummin sessions and he has to live his life with a cucumba up his fukin arse with his eye lids cut open and his hands cut off so he cant kill him self hahahahahahahahahahahaha

IN THE WORDS OF SHAKA KAHN
"PRRRAIIISE THE LORD"

I bet he wishes he would of killed him self now.

i know what suicidal is but god damn mother fucker should of killed his self a very different way.if he digs trains stand in front you got to not be pussy though or lay your head and splice ugh horrible. :eek:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vegasgrower

Even if he's crazy he should be locked up for the rest of his life

---

Why, so Innocent taxpayers can pay for this sick human being to live for another several decades. This man should be put down...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by robert42

yes yes yes
HE DESERVES TO DIE 11 TIMES.

---

:rolleyes:

Yeah, but only kill him 10 times - then keep him guessing as to when the final death will be exacted from him...that'll really mess his head up!

yeah he should be tried for murder, and the death penalty...?, well if those are the rules in the state of California so be it.

manslaughter x 11........i dont know...........im too tired to think about that shit right now.

Why kill him? That's doing him a fucking favor. The man WANTS to die.

I say lock him up in a mental ward for the rest of his life. With no parole. Mental wards blow. It's punishment enough.

But if I were feeling compassionate, I would say put him down. I feel really sorry for the poor guy. We all make mistakes, you know? He just maede a really fucking big one.

Oh, and putting someone to death costs more then locking someone up for life. Usually 2-3 times as much. So, in regards to the taxpayer comment, it's actually more expensive for you to have our justice system put people down.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Encatuse

Oh, and putting someone to death costs more then locking someone up for life. Usually 2-3 times as much. So, in regards to the taxpayer comment, it's actually more expensive for you to have our justice system put people down.

---

Why not just take out a gun and shoot him in the head? that seems like a pretty damn cheap way of killing someone to me... lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by clevemire

Hell yeah he should be put down. He obviously doesn't care about other human life (let alone his own), so why should other human life care about him?

Bury him.

---

thats the funniest shit i have heard all nite :D hahaha


but i agree with az666 , i dont beleave in death penality.......plus i think a life time of getin fucked in the ass :eek: and bein sumones fish :rolleyes: is by far the worse punishment ;)

send him sum TUCKS pads

2 wrongs never make a right! fuck the death penalty

Since I believe suicide to be the most selfish act , I also believe if you want to top yourself you should at least do it in a way that does not endanger others, and I also believe in the death penalty , I say shoot him !