Originally Posted by dragonrider
You were implying that anyone with a 401k automatically has a stake in the success of oil companies and that a windfall profit tax on oil companies would hurt anyone with a 401k. That's not true.
Again, I'm NOT in favor of a windfall profit tax on oil companies, but I was objecting to the logic that said it would hurt anyone with a 401k.
Now you are saying that SMART investors are invested in oil stocks, while also warning that oil stocks will be hurt by a windfall profit tax. Maybe a smart investor would guage whether this new tax would hurt oil companies as much as you say, then decide what are the odds of the tax passing, consider what are the other factors affecting oil stock proces, and then decide if now is a good time to buy, hold or sell oil stocks.
And then there are other people who base their investment decisions on more than just the numbers.