Originally Posted by Hardcore Newbie
I disagree. Who are you to say "it's impossible to lose faith"? How do you back up this claim? Faith is not evidence, faith is not knowledge, faith is not proof. Faith by definition is the exact opposite of these things, faith is more equivalent to hope than anything. How can you say it's impossible to lose faith? Losing faith is very possible, because i have believed in god, and now I don't. If you're trying to tell me that i didn't believe in god as a child, you're mistaken. I can *prove* that someone can lose faith, keep reading.
"Rooted and grounded in truth" is something I've heard of before. Just because someone is rooted and standing their ground firmer than another, that doesn't make their beliefs *more true*, for lack of better words at this moment.
If we have 3 people A, B and C, and 2 of them, A and B, have been told as children their multiplication tables without an explanation as to how they work. they're just given the table and expected to memorize it. There's a problem with this multiplication table tho, it states that 2x2=5. But since the children don't know how multiplication works, they use the multiplication table without giving a second thought as to whether it could be wrong. C comes along, who has actually learned how multiplication works, and tells them that 2x2=4, and can demonstrate why this is so over and over. B decides that, since he now knows how to multiply, he stops believing that 2x2=5. A takes what his teacher taught him as proof, and he is very rooted and grounded in "the truth".
Now, this story is NOT meant as a comparison of logic and belief, although it is a decent simplification of that as well. This story is meant to show that just because someone is very grounded in their beliefs, and believes it whole heartedly, it doesn't make them right. It also shows that someone can believe and then disbelieve, or "lose faith".