Why music really is getting louder

From The Times
June 4, 2007
Why music really is getting louder-Arts & Entertainment-Music-TimesOnline

Why music really is getting louder
Adam Sherwin, Media Correspondent

Dad was right all along â?? rock music really is getting louder and now recording experts have warned that the sound of chart-topping albums is making listeners feel sick.

That distortion effect running through your Oasis album is not entirely the Gallagher brothersâ?? invention. Record companies are using digital technology to turn the volume on CDs up to â??11â?�.

Artists and record bosses believe that the best album is the loudest one. Sound levels are being artificially enhanced so that the music punches through when it competes against background noise in pubs or cars.

Britainâ??s leading studio engineers are starting a campaign against a widespread technique that removes the dynamic range of a recording, making everything sound â??loudâ?�.

â??Peak limitingâ?� squeezes the sound range to one level, removing the peaks and troughs that would normally separate a quieter verse from a pumping chorus.

The process takes place at mastering, the final stage before a track is prepared for release. In the days of vinyl, the needle would jump out of the groove if a track was too loud.

But today musical details, including vocals and snare drums, are lost in the blare and many CD players respond to the frequency challenge by adding a buzzing, distorted sound to tracks.

Oasis started the loudness war and recent albums by Arctic Monkeys and Lily Allen have pushed the loudness needle further into the red.

The Red Hot Chili Peppersâ?? Californication, branded â??unlistenableâ?� by studio experts, is the subject of an online petition calling for it to be â??remasteredâ?� without its harsh, compressed sound.

Peter Mew, senior mastering engineer at Abbey Road studios, said: â??Record companies are competing in an arms race to make their album sound the â??loudestâ??. The quieter parts are becoming louder and the loudest parts are just becoming a buzz.â?�

Mr Mew, who joined Abbey Road in 1965 and mastered David Bowieâ??s classic 1970s albums, warned that modern albums now induced nausea.

He said: â??The brain is not geared to accept buzzing. The CDs induce a sense of fatigue in the listeners. It becomes psychologically tiring and almost impossible to listen to. This could be the reason why CD sales are in a slump.â?�

Geoff Emerick, engineer on the Beatlesâ?? Sgt. Pepper album, said: â??A lot of what is released today is basically a scrunched-up mess. Whole layers of sound are missing. It is because record companies donâ??t trust the listener to decide themselves if they want to turn the volume up.â?�

Downloading has exacerbated the effect. Songs are compressed once again into digital files before being sold on iTunes and similar sites. The reduction in quality is so marked that EMI has introduced higher-quality digital tracks, albeit at a premium price, in response to consumer demand.

Domino, Arctic Monkeysâ?? record company, defended its bandâ??s use of compression on their chart-topping albums, as a way of making their music sound â??impactfulâ?�.

Angelo Montrone, an executive at One Haven, a Sony Music company, said the technique was â??causing our listeners fatigue and even pain while trying to enjoy their favourite musicâ?�.

In an open letter to the music industry, he asked: â??Have you ever heard one of those test tones on TV when the station is off the air? Notice how it becomes painfully annoying in a very short time? Thatâ??s essentially what you do to a song when you super-compress it. You eliminate all dynamics.â?�

Mr Montrone released a compression-free album by Texan roots rock group Los Lonely Boys which sold 2.5 million copies.

Val Weedon, of the UK Noise Association, called for a ceasefire in the â??loudness warâ?�. She said: â??Bass-heavy music is already one of the biggest concerns for suffering neighbours. It is one thing for music to be loud but to make it deliberately noisy seems pointless.â?�

Mr Emerick, who has rerecorded Sgt. Pepper on the original studio equipment with contemporary artists, admitted that bands have always had to fight to get their artistic vision across.

He said: â??The Beatles didnâ??t want any nuance altered on Sgt. Pepper. I had a stand-up row with the mastering engineer because I insisted on sitting in on the final transfer.â?�

The Beatles lobbied Parlophone, their record company, to get their records pressed on thicker vinyl so they could achieve a bigger bass sound.

Bob Dylan has joined the campaign for a return to musical dynamics. He told Rolling Stone magazine: â??You listen to these modern records, theyâ??re atrocious, they have sound all over them. Thereâ??s no definition of nothing, no vocal, no nothing, just like â?? static.â?�

Studio sound

â?? The human ear responds to the average sound across a piece of music rather than peaks and crescendos. Quiet and loud sounds are squashed together, decreasing the dynamic range, raising the average loudness

â?? The saturation level for a sound signal is digital full scale, or 0dB. In the 1980s, the average sound level of a track was -18dB. The arrival of digital technology allowed engineers to push finished tracks closer to the loudest possible, 0dB

â?? The curves of a sound wave, which represent a wide dynamic range, become clipped and flattened to create â??square wavesâ?� which generate a buzzing effect and digital distortion on CD players

yup its all true. You can attribute most of the records being louder nowadays to serious overcompression. Everybody is trying to make their record sound louder than the next one. SIGH

While I have a massive CD collection and only 3 records, I can honestly say the records do sound better. Argh, it's right up there with the "superior DVD sound" that annoys me so much.

there is a wider frequency range with vinyl, digital just doesn't have the same range, vinyl usually sounds better, unless it's one of those new records that are pressed like shit.

i wanted to be a musician, but now i think the music industry is going to hell too. maybe ill play on the corner for dollars.
p.s. new music is usually shit