Saltwater Aquariums

[hydroponicphx]

Hey,
I was just wondering how many people had saltwater aquariums, what your experiences are with it, how much time you spend caring for it, etc, etc?
I am thinking of starting one, but it really depends on how much time I have to devote to it. I know its expensive, but thats not really my concern.
Thanks

[THClord]

Saltwater aquariums are very hard and a LOT of work and a LOT of money.

[luvfriday]

I had a salt water fish tank for about 3 years, and growing hydroponically is nothing compared to the money, time, work it took. Besides salt buildup all around the aquarium any you put 2 fish in the tank 1 will beat up the other and that makes them sick.

Star fish die in days and are a mess, crabs get out and they will be running around your house, eels jump out and eat the alge eater even though the fish store says no way no one eats the alge eater. No live rocks live long unless your trying to keep live rocks not fish.

I went and got a cat and life has been much more entertaining. You can plan on spending half a day every 2 weeks. NOt including if you need to go get your water for the water change. When you say money, we are talking $1000 at least in the first 6 months and I had a 20 gallon aquarium............and it took that much time.

[silkyblue]

If you get a salt water tank system in your house

hire a specialist to take care of the tank, its a full time job

if money is no object

build a room just for the care of the tanks

you will need more than one

my daughter was a wreck bcoz her yellow fish the kids named Dory was sick and dieing and she did everything right

it wasnt pretty on the tx with the 'pet world' owner trying everything but
cottage chees and raw hamburger for the pretty yellow salt water fish that died in front of the children OMG!

then the rest of the OTHER fish in the salt water '2 hundred gallon octagon shaped tank' freaked out and they died

moral of story

watch Nemo the movie

its really cute

[pkunk35]

Thought I would chime in with my 1st post on this topic as it seems the answers are a little negative, but very understandable. Many people get off on the wrong foot with fishkeeping.

I've been keeping tanks for about 8 years, although currently I am without one as I have just moved. I've setup and taken care of dozens of tanks from as small as 1/2 gallon glass bowls to 200 gallon coral reef setups. I'm no expert, just an enthusiast, but I have read a LOT of material on fish keeping. I've also helped to train dolphins in an OCEAN environment, so believe i have a unique perspective...

They can cost a lot of money, especially saltwater reef tanks, and yes, can be a very time consuming hobby. But I truly believe that a properly setup reef/fish tank is one of the most amazing things behold.
I mean, c'mon, you got a freaking living coral reef in your living room!
And the price range of a tank is huge...the more money you spend, the easier it will be, but Aquarium keeping is HUGE on DIY projects, so I have seen 50 gallon setups put together for less than a couple of hundred bucks, and this includes lights and fish. But if you got money, so much the better in this hobby...

Some of the information you are getting from these posts are from people who it seems do not have much experience keeping saltwater animals. Animals such as eels and starfish and algae eater blennies do NOT belong together and certainly not in a 20 gallon tank!
I'm so sorry, luvfriday and silkyblue, for your experiences with horrible fish store owners. I have been victimized countless times.
Unless you know someone who is very good at fishkeeping, I generally suggest doing your own research before speaking with the fish store guy, and don't really "take his word for it" unless you have a good relationship with him. Online buying is awesome now. I suggest perusing some reputable online stores.

Make no mistake! This is a science! And a very new one, just like hydro. Read your ass off before you even consider buying anything larger than 30 gallons. In fact, read till your eyes drop ESPECIALLY if you buy a tank under 30 gallons, as this small volume will be even LESS forgiving (this is why the eel won't do well in 20 gallons!).
The key to success? GO SLOW. I'll tell you to go slow, but you won't do it anyway (none of us do! lol!). The SLOWER you go, the LESS expensive it will be, the LESS things will die.
PLAN everything like its your 1st grow :jointsmile:

I recommend to EVERYONE starting or experienced to read "The Conscientious Marine Aquarist" by Robert Fenner. Read this book and you are just going to be smarter. About fish anyway.

Sorry bout the long post, I just love saltwater fishkeeping. Done properly, I almost guarantee you will be HOOKED.
Let me know if you need any other resources or advice!

[dmahny88]

odd that i am posting this a year late but wtvr, it's my take on fish tanks;

I got a 60gal when i was 13 and kept it going for 5 or so years til i moved out and upgraded it with lights/corals mid-way through.
Basically learned a HELLOFALOT about fish+water in a year and never stopped learning..now im an ecology major if that tells you something. It is a WAY fun hobby if it INTRESTS you, you don't have to enjoy the labor of keeping it up but to stay dedicated to it week to week the tank has got to be a passion you enjoy to work on the way i see it.

And as said below, CMON, it's a frickin living coral reef in your living room??seriously stunning! even when the lights are off:D

Really liked having it, live rocks, corals, an enemanae (spell?) shrimp, snails, bunch a fish including a knarly lil huma huma(clown) trigger fish. loved those guys and their characters. If i did it again, i would be probably be like 30 something years old with a nice job and income enough to put in a solid setup with a high focus on my biological filtering, it would be a reef tank, and i would make all my designs toward low maintenance and weekly/daily jobs like water changes and water testing. i got a panther chameleon with a auto-mister like it's that hard to spray him neways but when i opted out of the fish thing for a while i realized how EASY a reptile like chamy is compared to SALTWATER! so...imho DO SALTWATER and do it LEGIT if any of you do want a tank and don't go shy on things like pumps and filters because the cost supercedes the work you're gonna have to do with a sloppy hassle of a saltwater tank

[fripclaksid]

teach me how to grow hydro and i will teach you anything and everything about aquariums. Aquarium maintenance is my profession.

[Vancefish]

I've been keeping a reef aquarium for about 10 years now. It can be a lot of work and through some web sites, and forums you can get great advise on building many pieces of equipment or modding cheap stuff to work like expensive equipment.

One HUGE key is to buy a book with a good compatibility chart. Many fish like to eat others. So knowing what will work with what is key.

Regular cleanings are necessary, However most important is the specifics of micro nutrients and good buffering.

ALL reef animals(corals, clams, Coraline algae,) need massive amounts of light. Like a plant they "photosynthesize" too.

The bigger the tank, the more stable. So, you'll have FAR FAR fewer issues buying a 280gallon tank, then if you buy a 50 gallon. Because the water takes longer to foul, you can have more animals for better bio-diversity.

As for anything dying. Many stores sell fish caught with Cyanide. Divers squirt it into holes in rocks, then when the fish tries to flee the diver grabs it. ISSUE is the fish looses it's digestive tract from the cyanide. So a week or so later it'll starve to death.

I have about 2000+ starfish in my tank. Not even sure I could kill them. So that wasn't an accurate statement by Luvfriday.

[Jord0713]

I've had a salt water aquarium for about 10 years...one of my favorite hobbies...my best advice is get the right set up the first time i.e filtration, lighting etc and you will save yourself ALOT of time and money. If you look at taking care and running this hobby as "labour intensive" then it probably isn't the hobby for you. Me personally with the right equipment it's not that much work really. Daily inspection and checking of water ph, nitrogen etc., might be a little algae scraping off the glass...maybe not if you have the right fish. Feeding if they need. All of this takes about 10-15 minutes a day...in my opinion not really that hard. Then I do a %25 water change once a month with aged synthetic salt water. Not that hard either :) As far as the fish go, just do your research...just like growing erb every fish has it's own characteristics and difficulty. yes some fish a hard to keep, some are very expensive and hard to keep, but with the right set up (equipment) and right knowledge of the fish you put in your tank, in my opinion salt water is no harder than fresh water set ups.